"Membre de la troupe de l'Opéra de Copenhague, Ylva Kihlberg fait ce qu'elle peut dans un rôle éponyme ajusté sur son beau et grand soprano lyrique, quand le spectacle plutôt froid de Kasper Holten nous laisse de marbre - alors qu'il devrait nous saisir à la gorge".
Klassisk
2011, nr. 22
af
af
Christine Christiansen
2011, nr. 22
"Et ret enigt anmelderkorps uddelte drøje hug ... dvd-optagelsen vinder i forhold til live-udgaven ... Hovedrollen synges og dramatiseres meget ekspressivt og ægte af den svenske sopran Ylva Kihlberg ... Det cirkulære handlingsforløb og den enkle scenografi virker stærkt og klart på skærmen. Her zoomes helt ind på sangernes udtryksfulde ansigterm deres forvredne kroppe og sorgtyngede bevægelser på scenen ... Ruders' afdæmpede og enkle musik serveres pletfrit af Det Kgl. Kapel med dets daværende chefdirigent Michael Schønwandt i spidsen ... Oplagt, negativ anmelderkritik af operaen eller ej".
The gramophone
2011 October
af
af
David Fanning
2011 October
"Vurdering: Editor's choice" - "The fount of creative energy that has sustained Poul Ruders since the late 1960s shows no sign of running dry ... Most recent of all is the Piano Concerto (2009-10), written for Vassily Primakov and delivered by him with a superb range of colour, attack and atmosphere ... Imagine the Russian's [Gubaidulina] symbolic sound world shot through with the energy of Ligeti and you have some idea of the rewards in store from this marvellous disc, all of which is superbly played and recorded".
International record review
2010 June
af
af
Richard Whitehouse
2010 June
"Musically, the work is descended from Berg, in that its free tonality provides an expressive focus without the schematic framework becoming inflexible ... Michael Schønwandt conducts with his customary flair, securing a comitted response from the Royal Danish Opera Orchestra, while Kasper Holten directs with the theatricl inventiveness and acuity that made his Ring cycle ... such an absorbing reinterpretation".
